The Best Wisconsin Cheese Mart Gifts
Curated by Pebbleton · Pebbli's Anything & Everything specialist · Updated for 2026Shopping for a Wisconsin Cheese Mart fan? These are the Wisconsin Cheese Mart pieces worth gifting — pulled from the full lineup and ranked so the most save-worthy, genuinely-useful picks rise to the top. Every one links straight to where you can buy it.
The standout in The Best Wisconsin Cheese Mart Gifts is the Wisconsin Cheese Mart 3rd Street Cheese & Sausage Gift ($65) — chosen because it actually gets used, not just unwrapped. The 20 picks below run $5–$180.
Wisconsin Cheese Mart3rd Street Cheese & Sausage GiftWisconsin Cheese Mart's 3rd Street Cheese & Sausage Gift is a genuinely giftable find, and one of our favorites in this guide. It's the kind of thoughtful pick that feels chosen for the person, not just pulled off a shelf. For a milestone or someone special, it's the kind of gift they'll remember.
$65 · Shop it →
Wisconsin Cheese MartArtisan Cheese of the Month ClubWisconsin Cheese Mart's Artisan Cheese of the Month Club is a genuinely giftable find, and one of our favorites in this guide. It's the kind of thoughtful pick that feels chosen for the person, not just pulled off a shelf. For a milestone or someone special, it's the kind of gift they'll remember.
$180 · Shop it →
Wisconsin Cheese MartBread Cheese - BaconWe keep coming back to Wisconsin Cheese Mart's Bread Cheese - Bacon — a genuinely giftable find that's hard to get wrong. It's the kind of thoughtful pick that feels chosen for the person, not just pulled off a shelf. It punches well above its price, which is exactly what you want in a stocking-filler or add-on.
$8 · Shop it →
Wisconsin Cheese Mart5 Year Aged CheddarWe keep coming back to Wisconsin Cheese Mart's 5 Year Aged Cheddar — a genuinely giftable find that's hard to get wrong. It's the kind of thoughtful pick that feels chosen for the person, not just pulled off a shelf. And at this price, it's an easy add to any gift — or a great little gift on its own.
$9 · Shop it →
Wisconsin Cheese MartAged 2 Year SwissWisconsin Cheese Mart's Aged 2 Year Swiss is a genuinely giftable find, and one of our favorites in this guide. It's the kind of thoughtful pick that feels chosen for the person, not just pulled off a shelf. It punches well above its price, which is exactly what you want in a stocking-filler or add-on.
$8 · Shop it →
Wisconsin Cheese MartAged Asiago Cold Pack Cheese SpreadWe keep coming back to Wisconsin Cheese Mart's Aged Asiago Cold Pack Cheese Spread — a genuinely giftable find that's hard to get wrong. It's the kind of thoughtful pick that feels chosen for the person, not just pulled off a shelf. It punches well above its price, which is exactly what you want in a stocking-filler or add-on.
$6 · Shop it →
Wisconsin Cheese MartAged Asiago SpreadAged Asiago Spread from Wisconsin Cheese Mart is a genuinely giftable find with real staying power. It's the kind of thoughtful pick that feels chosen for the person, not just pulled off a shelf. And at this price, it's an easy add to any gift — or a great little gift on its own.
$8 · Shop it →- Want it narrowed to one? Chat with a Pebbli penguin and get gifts picked for your person.Find my gift →
Wisconsin Cheese MartAged Brick with CarawayAged Brick with Caraway from Wisconsin Cheese Mart is a genuinely giftable find with real staying power. It's the kind of thoughtful pick that feels chosen for the person, not just pulled off a shelf. It punches well above its price, which is exactly what you want in a stocking-filler or add-on.
$16 · Shop it →
Wisconsin Cheese MartApple Smoked Garlic CheddarApple Smoked Garlic Cheddar from Wisconsin Cheese Mart is a genuinely giftable find with real staying power. It's the kind of thoughtful pick that feels chosen for the person, not just pulled off a shelf. And at this price, it's an easy add to any gift — or a great little gift on its own.
$7 · Shop it →
Wisconsin Cheese MartApplewood Smoked LandjaegerApplewood Smoked Landjaeger from Wisconsin Cheese Mart is a genuinely giftable find with real staying power. It's the kind of thoughtful pick that feels chosen for the person, not just pulled off a shelf. It punches well above its price, which is exactly what you want in a stocking-filler or add-on.
$15 · Shop it →
Wisconsin Cheese MartArtisan Assortment Gift BoxWe keep coming back to Wisconsin Cheese Mart's Artisan Assortment Gift Box — a genuinely giftable find that's hard to get wrong. It's the kind of thoughtful pick that feels chosen for the person, not just pulled off a shelf. It's a step-up gift for someone who really matters — memorable without being over the top.
$96 · Shop it →
Wisconsin Cheese MartBa Ba Blue, SmokedWe keep coming back to Wisconsin Cheese Mart's Ba Ba Blue, Smoked — a genuinely giftable find that's hard to get wrong. It's the kind of thoughtful pick that feels chosen for the person, not just pulled off a shelf. It punches well above its price, which is exactly what you want in a stocking-filler or add-on.
$9 · Shop it →
Wisconsin Cheese MartBaraboo BlueBaraboo Blue from Wisconsin Cheese Mart is a genuinely giftable find with real staying power. It's the kind of thoughtful pick that feels chosen for the person, not just pulled off a shelf. And at this price, it's an easy add to any gift — or a great little gift on its own.
$9 · Shop it →
Wisconsin Cheese MartBeef Summer Sausage - Applewood SmokedBeef Summer Sausage - Applewood Smoked from Wisconsin Cheese Mart is a genuinely giftable find with real staying power. It's the kind of thoughtful pick that feels chosen for the person, not just pulled off a shelf. It punches well above its price, which is exactly what you want in a stocking-filler or add-on.
$9 · Shop it →
Wisconsin Cheese MartBellavitano MerlotBellavitano Merlot from Wisconsin Cheese Mart is a genuinely giftable find with real staying power. It's the kind of thoughtful pick that feels chosen for the person, not just pulled off a shelf. And at this price, it's an easy add to any gift — or a great little gift on its own.
$7 · Shop it →
Wisconsin Cheese MartBenedictineWe keep coming back to Wisconsin Cheese Mart's Benedictine — a genuinely giftable find that's hard to get wrong. It's the kind of thoughtful pick that feels chosen for the person, not just pulled off a shelf. It punches well above its price, which is exactly what you want in a stocking-filler or add-on.
$10 · Shop it →
Wisconsin Cheese MartBessie's BlendBessie's Blend from Wisconsin Cheese Mart is a genuinely giftable find with real staying power. It's the kind of thoughtful pick that feels chosen for the person, not just pulled off a shelf. It punches well above its price, which is exactly what you want in a stocking-filler or add-on.
$9 · Shop it →
Wisconsin Cheese MartAsiago with Rosemary and Olive OilAsiago with Rosemary and Olive Oil from Wisconsin Cheese Mart is a genuinely giftable find with real staying power. It's the kind of thoughtful pick that feels chosen for the person, not just pulled off a shelf. And at this price, it's an easy add to any gift — or a great little gift on its own.
$7 · Shop it →
Wisconsin Cheese MartBaby Cheddar ColoredWisconsin Cheese Mart's Baby Cheddar Colored is a genuinely giftable find, and one of our favorites in this guide. It's the kind of thoughtful pick that feels chosen for the person, not just pulled off a shelf. It punches well above its price, which is exactly what you want in a stocking-filler or add-on.
$5 · Shop it →
Wisconsin Cheese MartBaby SwissWe keep coming back to Wisconsin Cheese Mart's Baby Swiss — a genuinely giftable find that's hard to get wrong. It's the kind of thoughtful pick that feels chosen for the person, not just pulled off a shelf. It punches well above its price, which is exactly what you want in a stocking-filler or add-on.
$8 · Shop it →
Frequently asked
What is the best pick in The Best Wisconsin Cheese Mart Gifts?
Our top pick is the Wisconsin Cheese Mart 3rd Street Cheese & Sausage Gift at $65 — it leads the list because it's genuinely useful and well-made, not a novelty.
How much do the best wisconsin cheese mart gifts cost?
The picks here range from $5 to $180, so there's an option for most budgets. The full list shows the price on every item.
What's a good budget option?
The best value pick is the Wisconsin Cheese Mart Baby Cheddar Colored at $5.
How are these gifts chosen?
Pebbli ranks gifts by how giftable they are and how often real people save them, then filters to the ones that fit this list. Every pick links straight to where you can buy it.
Still deciding? Let a penguin help.
Pebbli remembers who you're shopping for and narrows a whole catalog down to the one gift that fits — free, no guesswork.